Compare the Alfa Romeo Tonale vs BMW X1

Uncomfortable on bad roads, but fun on a twisty lane
Carwow’s own expert rating out of 10 - how our reviewers rate this car overall for value, comfort, kit and driving experience
wowscore
7/10
Fiddly screen controls, but a brilliant family SUV
Carwow’s own expert rating out of 10 - how our reviewers rate this car overall for value, comfort, kit and driving experience
wowscore
8/10

AI generated from our expert reviews

If you are weighing up the Alfa Romeo Tonale against the BMW X1, both deliver good headroom in the back seats for taller passengers. When the road turns twisty, each car keeps body lean well contained through the bends, with the Tonale remaining composed and the X1 avoiding too much roll even in its normal comfort setting. Inside, both infotainment touchscreens can be slightly sluggish to respond, but their cabin layouts differ when you want to change the temperature. The Tonale keeps its main climate controls on an accessible, separate row of physical buttons, whereas the X1 removes conventional switches entirely and relies on on-screen menus that can prove rather fiddly to adjust while you are on the move.

AI results may contain inaccuracies. Please check the details before making any financial decisions.

'From' prices stated are for the lowest priced version of the car. Price may vary based on the selected version.

'From' prices stated are for the lowest priced version of the car. Price may vary based on the selected version.

Compare the specs

Showing

Standard 1.5 MHEV Auto Petrol Automatic

Change version

Showing

Sport sDrive 20i MHT Step Auto Petrol Automatic

Change version

Standard kit

  • Android Auto
    Mirrors your Android phone's apps, like maps, music and messages, onto the car's touchscreen.
  • Apple CarPlay
    Mirrors your iPhone's apps, like maps, music and messages, onto the car's touchscreen.
  • Cruise control
    Holds a steady speed on the motorway without keeping your foot on the accelerator.
  • Navigation
    Built-in sat nav on the car's own screen, no phone needed.
  • Parking Sensors
    Beeps that get faster as you get closer to something while parking.
  • Touchscreen infotainment
    A touch-operated screen for media, settings and (often) navigation.
  • Cruise control
    Holds a steady speed on the motorway without keeping your foot on the accelerator.
  • Heated seats
    Warms the seat itself on cold mornings.
  • Parking Camera
    A rear (sometimes 360°) camera that shows what's behind you while parking.

Key information

Body type SUVs Body type SUVs
Fuel type Petrol Fuel type Petrol
Number of seats 5 Number of seats 5
Boot space, seats up 500 litres (4 suitcases) Boot space, seats up 500 litres (4 suitcases)
Boot space, seats down 1,550 litres Best Boot space, seats down 1,545 litres
External dimensions (L x W x H) 4,528 mm x 1,841 mm x 1,614 mm External dimensions (L x W x H) 4,505 mm x 1,845 mm x 1,642 mm
Towing capacity 1,500 kg Towing capacity 1,800 kg Best
First year tax rate £455 First year tax rate £455
Fuel economy
This measures how much fuel a car uses, according to official tests. It's measured in miles per gallon (MPG) and a higher number means the car is more fuel efficient.
49.6 mpg
Fuel economy
This measures how much fuel a car uses, according to official tests. It's measured in miles per gallon (MPG) and a higher number means the car is more fuel efficient.
49.6 mpg
Drive type Front wheel drive Drive type Front wheel drive
Insurance
The insurance group the car sits in, from 1 to 50. The lower the group, the cheaper it usually is to insure.
Group 28 · average
Insurance
The insurance group the car sits in, from 1 to 50. The lower the group, the cheaper it usually is to insure.
Group 25 · average Best
View full specs Hide full specs

Drivetrain & power

Engine name 1.5 MHEV Auto Engine name sDrive 20i MHT Step Auto
Engine size 1.5 L Petrol • 174 BHP Engine size 1.5 L Petrol • 170 BHP
Body type SUVs Body type SUVs
Fuel type Petrol Fuel type Petrol
Transmission Automatic Transmission Automatic
Drive type Front wheel drive Drive type Front wheel drive
Forward gears 7 Forward gears 7
Acceleration 8.5 s (0-60 mph) Acceleration 8.3 s (0-60 mph) Best

Dimensions & space

Number of seats 5 Number of seats 5
Number of doors 5 Number of doors 5
Boot (seats up) 500 litres Boot (seats up) 500 litres
Boot (seats down) 1,550 litres Best Boot (seats down) 1,545 litres
Length 4,528 mm Length 4,505 mm
Width 1,841 mm Width 1,845 mm
Height 1,614 mm Height 1,642 mm
Wheelbase 2.64 m Wheelbase 2.69 m
Turning circle 11.57 m Turning circle 11.7 m

Full features list

  • 19" Dark miron alloy wheels
  • 20" Diamond cut miron matte finish alloy wheels
  • Cloth - Black with electrowelded Biscione logo
  • Harman Kardon sound system
  • Metallic paint
  • Metallic paint with black roof
  • Open sunroof with black roof moldings
  • Solid paint with black roof
  • Special metallic paint
  • Special metallic paint with black roof
  • Special solid paint
  • Tri coat paint
  • Tri coat paint with black roof
  • 6 airbags
  • A
  • Anti-lock brake system
  • Autonomous emergency braking inter-urban
  • Electric parking brake with autohold
  • Electronic Stability Programme
  • Emergency braking pedestrian and vulnerable road users - interurban
  • Manual rear child locks
  • Rear seatbelt reminder alert
  • Three 3 point rear seatbelts
  • Tyre pressure monitoring system (TPMS)
  • Adaptive cruise control with Stop and Go
  • Alfa connect box
  • Alfa connect services
  • Alfa dna with esc off (3 modes + esc off)
  • Apple car play/Android Auto
  • Back up camera with dynamic lines
  • Drowsy driver detection
  • Forward collision warning
  • Front and rear parking sensors
  • Full tft instrument cluster - 12.3"
  • Intelligent speed assist
  • Lane support system
  • Passive / keyless entry (front doors)
  • Power assisted steering
  • Quick guide in english
  • Rotary shifter
  • Speed limiting device
  • Traffic sign recognition (w/navigation)
  • Warranty handbook uk
  • Wireless charging pad
  • e-Call (emergency call)
  • 4 Interior puddle lights
  • Auto headlamps with dusk sensor
  • Auto high beam
  • Auto wipers with rain sensor
  • Auto-dimming rear internal mirror
  • Black painted mirror caps
  • Black rubber window surround
  • Body colour door handles
  • Body colour rear roof spoiler
  • Chrome finishing tonale badge
  • Electric exterior mirrors (heated)
  • Electrical-folding exterior mirrors
  • Front and rear power windows with auto up/down and antipinch
  • Full LED rear lamps
  • LED 3rd brake light
  • LED daytime running lights
  • LED license plate light
  • Matrix full led headlamps with adaptive system and fog light function
  • Rear side wing doors
  • Rear wiper
  • Roof, hood and exterior mirrors protection
  • Shark fin antenna
  • Solid paint
  • Welcome/leaving lighting
  • 12V socket in boot
  • 2 way electric driver lumbar support
  • 6 Way manually adjustable driver and passenger seat
  • 60/40 Rear seats with ski pass
  • Black ceiling and pillars
  • Bottle storage 1l on door panel
  • Cloth upholstery
  • Dual zone air conditioning with aqs (with rear airvents)
  • Front armrest (integrated in the central tunnel)
  • Front headrests
  • Front usb plug type a + c (charge + data)
  • Front/rear floor mats
  • Mono colour ambient light (included in domelamp)
  • Overhead console with domelamp led and switches
  • PTC heater
  • Rear air vents
  • Rear central armrest and 3 headrests
  • Rear usb plug type a + c (charge)
  • Seat belt height adjustment
  • Single front passenger seat
  • Softskin ip dashboard and upper door panels
  • Sport leather steering wheel with start button
  • Sunvisor mirror with light (driver and passenger)
  • 17" Dark finish diamond aero alloy wheels
  • Black and white alfa romeo logo center wheel caps
  • Fix and go puncture repair kit
  • Summer tires
  • Capless fuel filler
  • Keyless Go
  • Vehicle theft alarm with hood protection and intrusion sensor (thatcham)
  • 10.25" radio touchscreen
  • 6 Speakers sound system
  • DAB digital audio broadcast
  • 18" Star spoke alloy wheels finished in refined silver - Style 865
  • Active seat for driver and front passenger - electrically adjustable lumbar support
  • Aluminium shadow brushed interior trim
  • BMW Individual special paint
  • Cloth - Anthracite
  • Econeer - Bicolour blue
  • Econeer upholstery
  • Electric front seats with memory and door mirror memory
  • Front sports seats
  • Harman/Kardon surround sound audio system
  • Heated steering wheel
  • High gloss black interior trim finishers with pearl chrome highlights
  • Luggage net
  • Metallic paint
  • Model designation deletion
  • Panoramic opening glass sunroof
  • Perforated Veganza upholstery
  • Sliding rear seats - Mechanical fore and aft adjustment 130mm
  • Sun protection glass
  • Towbar
  • Veganza perforated - Atlas grey/Smoke white
  • Veganza perforated - Black
  • Veganza perforated - Castanea
  • Veganza perforated - Smoke white
  • Anti-lock Brake System and Electronic Brakeforce Distribution
  • Automatic Stability Control (ASC)
  • Automatic hold function
  • BMW emergency call
  • Braking readiness
  • Cornering brake control (CBC)
  • Crash Sensor - activates hazard/interior lighting + unlocks doors
  • Driver/Front Passenger airbags
  • Driver/front passenger side airbags
  • Dry braking
  • Dynamic brake control
  • Dynamic stability control + (DSC+)
  • Electromechanical parking brake
  • Energy recovery system
  • First aid kit
  • Front and rear brake discs
  • Front and rear head airbags
  • Front passenger airbag deactivation
  • Integrated brake system
  • PC iBrake PostCrash approach control warning with light braking function
  • Rear door child safety locks
  • Three point seat belts in all seats
  • Tyre pressure monitor
  • Warning triangle
  • BMW radiator grille with grille struts, end face black high-gloss, radiator grille frame chrome high-gloss
  • Badge on engine compartment lid and tailgate
  • Body colour door mirrors
  • Contoured rear roof spoiler in vehicle colour with side aeroblades in black high-gloss
  • Dynamic brake lights
  • Electric adjustable heated door mirrors
  • Electric windows - front and rear, with open/close fingertip control, anti-trap facility and comfort closing
  • Exterior mirror including electric fold in function
  • Folding door handles integrated flush with surface
  • Follow me home headlights
  • Front bumper panel with air inlet in matt black
  • Front door exit lights
  • Full LED headlights
  • Heated rear window
  • High gloss shadowline
  • Invisible exhaust tailpipe
  • LED 3rd brake light integrated in rear roof spoiler
  • LED daytime running lights
  • LED number plate light
  • M roof rails high gloss shadow line
  • Matt black roof strips
  • Model inscription on right tailgate
  • Rain sensor including auto headlights activation
  • Rear bumper panel with two L-shaped trims In pearl chrome
  • Rear side wing doors
  • Rear wiper
  • Sill cover in body colour
  • Solid paint
  • Trailer stabilisation logic
  • Welcome lighting
  • Window washer nozzle for rear view camera
  • Windscreen wipers front with heated washer nozzles
  • Active Guard + lane departure warning, speed limiting, front collision warning, Left turn warning with brake function and evasion assist
  • Attentiveness assist
  • Automatic start/stop function
  • BMW Live Cockpit Plus with 10.25" instrument cluster and 10.7" display
  • BMW Operating system 9 with BMW Maps, real-time traffic information, in-car experiences, remote services and smartphone integration
  • BMW Teleservices
  • Brake pad wear indicator
  • Condition based service
  • Connected eDrive Services
  • Cruise control
  • Drive off assistant
  • Electrically opening/closing tailgate with opening/closing with remote control and contactless opening and closing
  • Flat air vents on instrument panel in high gloss black, adjustable slats with elements in pearl chrome
  • Language version English
  • My Modes
  • Parking Assistant with Reversing Assistant, active PDC, Lateral Parking Aid, Rear View Camera and Park Distance Control
  • Personal Profile - automatic lock when driving away selectable
  • Servotronic Power Assisted Steering
  • Tyre puncture warning system
  • Widescreen display
  • iDrive controller
  • EU6 emissions management
  • Gear selector switch with toggle operation
  • Larger Fuel Tank
  • Performance Control
  • Petrol Particulate Filter
  • Standard suspension
  • Steptronic transmission with double clutch
  • 12V - Power sockets with front centre console and luggage compartment
  • 2 bag hooks in luggage compartment
  • 2 cup holders in front
  • 2 front reading lights
  • 2 rear centre reading lights
  • 2 x USB Type C ports for charging in front centre console + 1 x USB Type C ports for charging in rear centre console
  • 3 rear headrests
  • 3 seat bench in 2nd row
  • 3 upper retaining strap clips integrated into rear panels of seat backrests
  • 4 grab handles
  • 40:20:40 split folding rear seats
  • Ambient interior lighting
  • Anthracite Velour front and rear floormats
  • Bottle trays in all doors
  • Child seat ISOFIX attachment for two outer rear seats and front passenger seat with anchorage points
  • Cloth upholstery
  • Clothes hook rear
  • Comfort front seats
  • Driver and front passenger heated seats
  • Dual zone automatic air conditioning
  • Footrest and pedals in black plastic
  • Front and rear door pockets
  • Front and rear footwell lighting
  • Front armrest with integrated control panel
  • Front centre console storage compartment
  • Front centre console trim in black high-gloss
  • Front/rear adjustable head restraints
  • Glove compartment
  • Interior door handle recess light on all doors
  • Light on right in luggage compartment
  • Manual steering column height and depth adjustment
  • Middle centre console storage compartment
  • One piece parcel shelf opens together with tailgate and removable
  • Rear armrest in door trim panel
  • Single front passenger seat
  • Sport leather multifunction steering wheel with thumbrests and operation of instrument display, audio, telephone and driver assistance
  • Storage compartment lighting in centre console and storage tray in centre stack
  • Storage compartment net in left side trim panel
  • Storage compartment with folding cover under centre console armrest cushion
  • Storage tray in right side trim panel
  • Sun visors with illuminated vanity mirrors
  • Tilt adjustment incl. cargo function of 2nd row of seats
  • Trim elements on steering wheel spokes in pearl chrome
  • Vanity mirror lights
  • Alarm system with tilt sensor, monitoring doors, bonnet interior and tailgate
  • Closing system with central locking
  • Locking wheel bolts
  • BMW Personal eSim
  • DAB Digital radio
  • Stereo speaker system with 6 speakers
  • 17" Star spoke alloy wheels finished in lightning grey - Style 875
  • Tyre repair kit plus
  • Matt quartz Silver grained interior trim

'From' prices stated are for the lowest priced version of the car. Price may vary based on the selected version.

'From' prices stated are for the lowest priced version of the car. Price may vary based on the selected version.

*Please contact the dealer for a personalised quote, including terms and conditions. Quote is subject to dealer requirements, including status and availability. Illustrations are based on personal contract hire, 9 month upfront fee, 48 month term and 8000 miles annually, VAT included.