Audi A3 vs BMW 1 Series vs Mercedes A-Class vs VW Golf

January 26, 2024 by

If you’re after a family hatchback with a touch of class, you’ll likely be looking at something German. Specifically, you’re probably considering the Audi A3, BMW 1 Series, Mercedes A-Class or the Volkswagen Golf.

But which of these cars is right for you? Well keep reading to find out a bit about each car. Once you’ve chosen the ideal model, follow the links to build your perfect car and get great offers from our network of trusted dealers.

Audi A3

The Audi A3 is a smart-looking car, both inside and out. The S-Line is the most stylish thanks to its larger alloy wheels and sporty body kit, and that version gets a handful of upgrades to the high-quality interior.

That S-Line model also gets a more sporty suspension setup which makes it the most fun to drive of all the A3s, although this does compromise the smooth ride comfort. The BMW 1 Series is also a better bet for those wanting to have a laugh on a twisty road.

There are a handful of petrol and diesel engine options on offer, and a plug-in hybrid which can do up to 40 miles on electric power alone. The pick of the range is the 1.5-litre petrol engine with 150hp paired to an automatic gearbox thanks to its blend of performance and economy.

BMW 1 Series

Those who like to have fun on a country road will be best off in the BMW 1 Series. It has sharp steering and a great suspension setup which makes it a joy to throw through corners, and it’s almost as comfortable as the Audi A3 as well.

Some might find the styling to be a little more awkward than the Audi or the Mercedes, however the M Sport trim goes some way to help this with larger wheels and a more aggressive body kit. The 1 Series also has a really well-made interior, and it’s available with an impressive amount of tech.

You have a few petrol and diesel engine options to choose from, although there’s no plug-in hybrid. The best all-rounder here is the 118i with an automatic gearbox. This 1.5-litre petrol engine has plenty of power, it’s smooth and it’ll return decent economy as well.

Mercedes A-Class

As soon as you sit behind the wheel in the Mercedes A-Class you’ll be wowed by its high-tech dashboard and the super-cool design. You could also argue that this is the most stylish car here as well, especially in AMG-Line trim with a handful of sporty upgrades.

The A-Class is easy and relaxing to drive and it’s available with loads of driver assistance tech, although adaptive cruise control is an expensive optional extra. It’s not quite as much fun through the bends as the BMW either.

The 1.3-litre petrol engine you get in the A200 may not seem that impressive on paper, but it’s actually perfectly adequate for zipping around town and it gets good fuel economy on motorways. There is also a diesel option, as well as a plug-in hybrid.

Volkswagen Golf

The ever-popular Volkswagen Golf has been synonymous with family hatchbacks for decades now, and with good reason. The latest version is spacious, practical and packed with all the tech you’ll ever need.

It’s a comfortable car to drive as well, although there’s not much to be had in the way of fun unless you go for the GTI or R performance versions. It’s also not the most exciting thing to look at compared to the Mercedes.

You have plenty of engine choices, including petrol, diesel and plug-in hybrid. The best choice here though is the 1.5-litre 150hp petrol with an automatic gearbox. It’s very similar to the unit you can get in the A3, so it offers the same combination of performance and economy.

Change cars with Carwow

Hopefully you’ve now got a better idea of which posh hatchback is best for you, so don’t forget to follow the links below each car and compare offers from our trusted dealers.

Carwow is your one-stop shop for changing cars. Not only can you save money on a new car, you can also sell your current car for a great price through the same network of trusted dealers. It’s as easy as uploading a few photos, answering some questions and watching the offers roll in.

Once you’ve accepted an offer for your old car, the dealer will come and pick it up at a time and place to suit you, and the money will be transferred straight into your account. It really is that easy. Tap the button below to get started today.

Volkswagen Golf

Family car icon that's comfortable and practical
7/10
£26,955 - £37,040
RRP
Read review Compare offers

Volkswagen Golf

Family car icon that's comfortable and practical
7/10
£26,955 - £37,040
RRP
Read review Compare offers