Compare the MG S9 vs Tesla Model Y
Carwow’s own expert rating out of 10 - how our reviewers rate this car overall for value, comfort, kit and driving experience
9/10
2026
Outstanding EV Award
Highly Commended
Carwow’s own expert rating out of 10 - how our reviewers rate this car overall for value, comfort, kit and driving experience
9/10
AI generated from our expert reviews
If you need extra passenger capacity or towing capability, the MG S9 provides a third row of seats and can tow more than the Tesla Model Y. Out on the road, the entry-level Model Y is still a hugely fast SUV that makes getting up to motorway speeds a breeze, whereas the S9 never feels very brisk, though it is quite smooth when accelerating. Their touchscreens also feel very different to use; the entry-level Model Y has a hyper-responsive display, but the S9 is dreadfully slow to respond to your touch. Both cars demand caution when changing lanes, however, because over-the-shoulder visibility is rather poor in the Model Y and could be better in the S9.
AI results may contain inaccuracies. Please check the details before making any financial decisions.
'From' prices stated are for the lowest priced version of the car. Price may vary based on the selected version.
Compare the specs
Standard kit
-
Android Auto
Mirrors your Android phone's apps, like maps, music and messages, onto the car's touchscreen.
-
Apple CarPlay
Mirrors your iPhone's apps, like maps, music and messages, onto the car's touchscreen.
-
Climate control
Automatically keeps the cabin at a set temperature, rather than a manual heater dial.
-
Cruise control
Holds a steady speed on the motorway without keeping your foot on the accelerator.
-
Heated seats
Warms the seat itself on cold mornings.
-
Navigation
Built-in sat nav on the car's own screen, no phone needed.
-
Parking Camera
A rear (sometimes 360°) camera that shows what's behind you while parking.
-
Parking Sensors
Beeps that get faster as you get closer to something while parking.
-
Touchscreen infotainment
A touch-operated screen for media, settings and (often) navigation.
-
Climate control
Automatically keeps the cabin at a set temperature, rather than a manual heater dial.
-
Cruise control
Holds a steady speed on the motorway without keeping your foot on the accelerator.
-
Heated seats
Warms the seat itself on cold mornings.
-
Leather seats
Leather (or leather-look) seat upholstery instead of cloth.
-
Navigation
Built-in sat nav on the car's own screen, no phone needed.
-
Parking Camera
A rear (sometimes 360°) camera that shows what's behind you while parking.
-
Touchscreen infotainment
A touch-operated screen for media, settings and (often) navigation.
Key information
| Body type SUVs | Body type SUVs, Hatchbacks |
| Available fuel types Hybrid | Available fuel types Electric |
| Number of seats 7 Best | Number of seats 5 |
| Boot space, seats up 332 litres (2 suitcases) | Boot space, seats up — |
| Boot space, seats down 1,026 litres | Boot space, seats down 2,118 litres Best |
| External dimensions (L x W x H) 4,983 mm x 1,967 mm x ?? mm | External dimensions (L x W x H) 4,797 mm x 1,982 mm x 1,624 mm |
| Towing capacity 2,000 kg Best | Towing capacity 1,600 kg |
| First year tax rate £115 | First year tax rate £10 Best |
|
Efficiency
Efficiency refers to how far an electric car travels on a given amount of energy, based on official tests. It is measured in miles per kilowatt-hour (mi/kWh).
|
Efficiency
Efficiency refers to how far an electric car travels on a given amount of energy, based on official tests. It is measured in miles per kilowatt-hour (mi/kWh).
|
|
Fuel economy
This measures how much fuel a car uses, according to official tests. It's measured in miles per gallon (MPG) and a higher number means the car is more fuel efficient.
|
Fuel economy
This measures how much fuel a car uses, according to official tests. It's measured in miles per gallon (MPG) and a higher number means the car is more fuel efficient.
|
|
Battery range
This refers to how many miles an electric car can complete on a fully charged battery, according to official tests.
|
Battery range
This refers to how many miles an electric car can complete on a fully charged battery, according to official tests.
|
| Battery size 24.7 kWh | Battery size 63 kWh |
| Drive type Front wheel drive | Drive type Rear wheel drive |
|
Insurance
The insurance group the car sits in, from 1 to 50. The lower the group, the cheaper it usually is to insure.
|
Insurance
The insurance group the car sits in, from 1 to 50. The lower the group, the cheaper it usually is to insure.
|
Drivetrain & power
| Engine name 1.5 T-GDI PHEV Auto | Engine name RWD Auto |
| Engine size 1.5 L Hybrid • 299 BHP | Engine size Electric • 299 BHP |
| Body type SUVs | Body type SUVs, Hatchbacks |
| Fuel type Hybrid | Fuel type Electric |
| Transmission Automatic | Transmission Automatic |
| Drive type Front wheel drive | Drive type Rear wheel drive |
| Forward gears 1 | Forward gears 1 |
| Acceleration 9.6 s (0-60 mph) | Acceleration 7.2 s (0-60 mph) Best |
| Battery size 24.7 kWh | Battery size 63 kWh |
|
Battery range
This refers to how many miles an electric car can complete on a fully charged battery, according to official tests.
|
Battery range
This refers to how many miles an electric car can complete on a fully charged battery, according to official tests.
|
Dimensions & space
| Number of seats 7 Best | Number of seats 5 |
| Number of doors 5 | Number of doors 5 |
| Boot (seats up) 332 litres | Boot (seats up) — |
| Boot (seats down) 1,026 litres | Boot (seats down) 2,118 litres Best |
| Length 4,983 mm | Length 4,797 mm |
| Width 1,967 mm | Width 1,982 mm |
| Height — | Height 1,624 mm |
| Wheelbase 2.92 m | Wheelbase 2.89 m |
| Turning circle 11.5 m | Turning circle 12.13 m |
Full features list
*Please contact the dealer for a personalised quote, including terms and conditions. Quote is subject to dealer requirements, including status and availability. Illustrations are based on personal contract hire, 9 month upfront fee, 48 month term and 8000 miles annually, VAT included.