Loading car reviews

Ferrari 458 Italia

Aggregated reviews, user reviews, videos, photos and stats

9.810
10
 
 
Ferrari 458
  • Look at that score!
  • Incredible speed
  • Stunning looks
  • No manual gearbox
  • Pricey
  • Nothing else...
Ferrari had been accused in the past of having turned into a marketing company, more concerned with selling gaudy trinkets to wealthy poseurs than designing and building fast sports cars – but the arrival of the 458 changed all that.

Interior

The driver-focussed interior is spartan but has everything that you need – even if the air-conditioning controls are awkwardly placed. The seats are supportive, grip well and remain comfortable enough for long journeys.

Driving

No-one has raised any concerns with how the 458 drives with every journo loving it. Most single the engine out for praise, but the seven-speed, twin-clutch gearbox and suspension have also won universal praise.

The Ferrari’s suspension is adjustable, which means that you can have it softer for the road for a (relatively) comfortable ride and then firm it up for the track giving inch-perfect handling.

Engines

The 562bhp, 4.5-litre V8 engine revs to a stratospheric 9,000rpm and makes the most glorious noise in the automotive world. Relentless urge and a willingness to rev mean that you will sometimes wish that it revved even higher!

Value for money

Not great value in the conventional sense, but if you’ve got the money to spend on a supercar then there is no more reliable, fast, or exciting place to put your money.

Worth noting

Britain’s McLaren’s MP4-12C was widely expected to trounce the 458. In reality most commentators prefer the Italian car, claiming that it gives more excitement and driver involvement.

Conclusion

This ‘pant-wettingly exciting’ supercar changed the rules of the game completely and is the benchmark by which all others are now measured. The great thing about the 458 is that delivers as a track or road car with aplomb – and manages to add reliability and usability to the mix. It is the closest thing to a perfect super-car that you can buy today.

To see how it compares to the McLaren MP4-12C, the 458's arch rival, check out this infographic we created comparing the Ferrari 458 and McLaren MP4-12C.

Read Ferrari 458 Italia reviews >>

Key Details

Price range:
£178,526 - £179,510
MPG:
21 - 24
Date released:
2009
Replacement due:
Not for a few years
Model history:
A more hardcore Scuderia version is expected soon.
Options to go for:
Sat-nav, it doesn’t come as standard
Options to avoid:
You can order almost any part in carbon fibre, but don't, it'll just look silly!
Other variants:
There's also a convertible, the 458 Spider.
Read Ferrari 458 Italia reviews >>
Average score for the 458 Italia:
9.810
based on 11 expert reviews

We aggregate the most helpful Ferrari 458 Italia reviews from the best publications.

Compiled expert reviews

1010

The 458 is a total success.

Read full review
  • WhatCar
1010

...the 458 Italia is impossibly, pant-wettingly exciting.

Read full review
  • PistonHeads
  • | Riggers
  • | 15/12/2010
910

The price may be higher than the old F430, but the 458 is a much more complete package.

Read full review
  • Autocar
  • | Jamie Corstorphine
  • | 02/11/2009
1010

It’s expensive and not everyone thinks it is beautiful, but as a driving machine it is mighty impressive...

Read full review
  • AutoExpress
  • | Paul Bailey
  • | Nov-09
1010

Is the 458 Italia really worth an estimated £60k more than an Audi R8 V10? Judging by the number of five-star ratings in our spec sheet, yes.

Read full review
  • Car
  • | Chris Chilton
  • | 05/11/2009
910

The steering is sublime, its engine a masterpiece that's amazingly tractable at low revs...

Read full review
  • Pistonheads
  • | Kyle Fortune
  • | 19/11/2009
1010

Faster than a 430 Scuderia, yet more docile, better mannered and softer riding.

Read full review
  • Telegraph
  • | Andrew English
  • | 20/11/2009
1010

It's an extraordinary, an irresistible, combination of attributes.

Read full review
  • Independent
  • | John Simister
  • | 20/12/2009
1010

The technology-laden new 458 Italia is an engineering triumph, with an excellent V8 engine, brilliant handling and quintessential Ferrari looks.

Read full review
  • AutoExpress
  • | Ross Pinnock
  • | Jul-10
1010

...even considering the wonderfully desirable 599 GTO, arguably it is the 458 Italia that is Ferrari’s greatest achievement.

Read full review
  • Autocar
  • | 12/08/2010
-10

Group Test - Ferrari 458 vs McLaren MP4-12C.

Result - Victory for the Ferrari!

Read full review
  • AutoExpress
  • | Jun-11
Now watch some Ferrari 458 Italia videos >>
No user reviews added yet. Be the first to tell us what it's like!

  • Ferrari-458 (2)
  • Ferrari-458 (3)
  • Ferrari-458 (4)
  • Ferrari-458 (5)
  • Ferrari-458 (6)
  • Ferrari-458 (7)
  • Ferrari-458 (8)
  • Ferrari-458 (9)
  • Ferrari-458 (10)
  • Ferrari-458 (11)
  • Ferrari-458 (12)
  • Ferrari-458 (13)
  • Ferrari-458 (14)
  • Ferrari-458 (15)
  • Ferrari-458 (16)
  • Ferrari-458 (17)
  • Ferrari-458 (18)
  • Ferrari-458 (19)